Case Study: Smoothing volatility of miners’ future rewards with BTC put options

17 NOV 2023 | VIEWS | 3 MIN READ

Mining companies, driven by the recent cryptocurrency rally and ahead of Bitcoin’s upcoming halving in April 2024, are moving quickly to secure profits. The pressing concern for many miners is to safeguard holdings from potential price drops in a market that’s prone to fluctuations and uncertain cash flows. With future rewards at stake, it becomes vital to employ strategies to ensure profitability and meet financial commitments.

In this case study, we’ll explore how Wintermute Asia assisted a Bitcoin miner in protecting his significant BTC holdings against the potential risk of market downturns.

The challenge of securing mining profitability in a volatile market environment

A Bitcoin miner faced the challenge of managing the uncertainty surrounding their future mining rewards. By early June 2022, the price of BTC was hovering around $29,000, and the miner was concerned about potential price drops that could impact the value of his BTC holdings and future mining rewards, which were expected to reach a total of $2.9 million worth of BTC. For example, a price decrease from $29,000 to $19,000, would imply a loss of $1 million (-34% of the initial value), risking the profitability of his mining activity.

How buying put options can hedge BTC value

To mitigate this risk, the miner decided to protect his BTC holdings using put options at $26,000 for a premium cost of $120,000, equivalent to 4% of the current value of the original notional. These put options provide a form of insurance for his BTC holdings, enabling him to sell Bitcoin at a predetermined price if the market experiences a significant downturn.

Wintermute Asia’s no fees & direct access to major Options liquidity sources and efficient capital management framework played a vital role in crafting a customized and cost-effective solution to protect the miner’s assets during market volatility.

Results: The miner’s holdings stayed safe regardless of market swings

Scenario 1: Price declined and miner was protected

By July 2022, the price of Bitcoin had fallen from the initial price of $29,000 to $19,000, more than 30% decline. However, the miner exercised the BTC put options at a strike price of $26,000, mitigating potential losses to a maximum of -14.5% under the initial value of his BTC.

• BTC Value at Initial Price = $29,000 x 100 BTC = $2.9 million


• BTC Value at Expiry= $19,000 x 100 BTC = $1.9 million


• Option Value = ($26,000 – $19,000) x 100 BTC = $0.7 million


• Total P&L = $1.9 million (Value at Expiry) + $0.7 million (Option Value) – $2.9 million (Value at Initial Price) – $0.12 million (Premium) = -$0.42 million (-14.5%)

Scenario 2: If prices had increased, miner would have retained upside potential

In the hypothetical case that the price of Bitcoin would have increased, for example, soaring from an initial $29,000 to $39,000, the BTC miner would have made the decision not to exercise his put options, choosing instead to hold onto his Bitcoin holdings. By doing so, he would have capitalized on the substantial increase in value, achieving a 30% profit on his initial investment as the Bitcoin price reached new heights.

• BTC Value at Initial Price = $29,000 x 100 BTC = $2.9 million


• BTC Value at Expiry = $39,000 x 100 BTC = $3.9 million


• Total P&L = $3.9 million (Value at Expiry) – $2.9 million (Value at Initial Price) – $0.12 million (Premium) = $0.88 million (+30%)

Key Takeaways

This case study emphasizes the significance of employing risk management and financial tools in the Bitcoin mining industry. Using derivative products, like BTC put options, is valuable for addressing challenges related to price fluctuations and uncertain cash flow.

• Through the purchase of BTC put options, the miner successfully shielded their holdings and future rewards from potential declines in Bitcoin price


• This approach also balanced the protection of the investment during market turbulence with the potential for gains in case of price increases

—

This material is provided by Wintermute Asia solely for informational purposes, and is intended only for sophisticated, institutional investors. Specifically, derivatives trading with Wintermute Asia is not suitable for retail persons in the United Kingdom. Trading and investing in digital assets and derivative transactions involve significant risks including price volatility and illiquidity and may not be suitable for all investors. Wintermute Asia is not liable whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from the use of this material. This material does not constitute an offer or commitment, a solicitation of an offer, or commitment, or any advice or recommendation, to enter into or conclude any transactions, or to provide investment services in any state or country where such an offer or solicitation or provision would be illegal.

Wintermute Asia does not give any representations or warranties in relation to the accuracy, validity or complicity of the information of this material, including without limitation the factual information obtained from publicly available sources considered by Wintermute Asia to be reliable; and do not accept any liability for any consequences of using the information contained in this material, and for the applicability of this material for the specific purposes and objectives of this material recipients. Any opinions or estimates expressed herein reflect a judgment made by the author(s) as of the date of publication, and are subject to change without notice. Neither this material nor any copy thereof may be taken, reproduced, or redistributed, directly or indirectly, without prior written permission of Wintermute Asia.